Skip to main content

The Man Of A Thousand Faces

July 2024
1min read

PLYMOUTH , Vt, Dec., 1925-Up here in the cold, silent hills of Vermont, his old friends and neighbors are afraid that success may be spoiling Colonel John Coolidge’s son Calvin. As a boy, to be sure, he was regarded as a bit of a chatterbox, and his grandmother, Mrs. Galusha Coolidge, would lock him in the attic until he quieted down, but Amherst and law studies were supposed to have sobered him up. It was old Vermont speaking when he wrote his father that “I see no need of a wife as long as I have my health.” He was twenty-nine. Yet almost overnight, which is to say four years later and while still robust, he married Miss Grace Goodhue, a goodlooking but gadabout society girl from Northampton, Massachusetts.


The rest of the President’s career is pretty well known in these parts, since nothing has ever happened here to match the event which took place by lamplight at 2:47 A.M. of August 3, 1923, when the Colonel, who is a notary public and was wearing a nightshirt, swore in his son, who was in shirtsleeves, as President of the United States. The change in the President’s personality is laid to gregarious Mrs. Coolidge, to the effects of “sophisticated” life in Northampton and then Boston, and to the influence of his political mentor, Frank Waterman Stearns, the Boston dry-goods merchant who helped Mr. Coolidge win the governorship of the Bay State. It is said that Mr. Stearns plays Bute to his George III, or, in more modern terms, Mark Hanna to his William McKinley.

It is rumored locally that Mr. Stearns, an Amherst graduate like the President, is motivated by a desire to offset Harvard influence in Boston and Washington by getting more Amherst men into public life. He and Mr. Coolidge spend a good deal of time together, apparently in comfortable silence, but the mentor sometimes gives counsel in written notes, one of which we have been shown.


“When you meet people,” wrote Mr. Stearns to his younger friend, “and especially when they are invited to meet you, if you would give them a pleasant smile, even without speaking, it would make the trick complete.…”

The photographs reproduced here, all taken this year, impress Plymouth, Vermont, as evidence that city life and its riotous living have overtaken the thirtieth president. Has he taken Mr. Stearns’ advice too seriously? One lady, who would not give her name but stated that she had been several times all the way to Rutland and had seen the advertisements in front of that city’s motion-picture theater, studied the photographs and referred disdainfully to Mr. Coolidge “making all those faces.” He reminded her, she said, of Lon Chaney, the “Man of a Thousand Faces.” If “Smiling CaI,” as he often now is called in his birthplace, runs again in 1928, he may have trouble holding all twelve of the local electors in the Republican column.


We hope you enjoy our work.

Please support this 72-year tradition of trusted historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it with a donation to American Heritage.